We need to talk about discrimination, bullying and harassment at work
What is this study about?
This study is part of the Tackling Inequalities and Discrimination Experiences in health Services (TIDES) study.
In the UK-based National Health Service (NHS), these experiences are more common among migrant and racially minoritised healthcare staff groups. These groups are also over-represented in lower paid roles and in formal disciplinary actions and under-represented in senior positions.
In this study, we wanted to better understand:
- how the healthcare working environment and culture is experienced by staff and how this affects experiences of discrimination, bullying, and harassment
- how and why this environment might lead to poorer experiences for racial and ethnic minority staff groups
- what role discrimination, bullying and harassment have in maintaining unfair differences in the workplace environment
How did they do the study?
The TIDES study team interviewed 46 healthcare staff who were training and working in NHS trusts within London (UK) from January 2019 to February 2020.
This included student nurses/midwives, healthcare assistants, nursing associates, as well as qualified nurses and midwives at different levels of seniority.
In these interviews, researchers asked about staff member’s experiences of and witnessing discrimination, bullying, and harassment at work, and about their experiences of career progression and disciplinary action.
The interviews were then analysed using thematic analysis. The researchers:
- read and re-read transcripts of the interviews
- searched for patterns in responses (how and what was said)
- looked for similarities and differences between what the healthcare staff spoke about and how they spoke about them
What did they find?
- Working in the NHS can mean operating in a high pressure, complex and challenging environment, with high workloads and short staffing. There is also a social hierarchy for staff working in the NHS that is largely dictated by role and pay grade. Those lower down the hierarchy described feeling less valued, important, respected, as well as having less power and decision-making ability
- This working environment affected staff health and well-being directly but also indirectly, by exacerbating discrimination, bullying and harassment behaviours. This affected how people were treated at work, their opportunities for career progression, and how they felt about work
- Those interviewed reported that staff from racially minoritised and migrant groups were more vulnerable to experiences of discrimination, bullying and harassment in the workplace. They also reported having to work harder to climb the career ladder, feeling resigned to being unfairly treated, and/or tired of battling the system
- They indicated that this was linked to racially minoritised groups being over-represented at lower levels of the hierarchy. Also, to stereotyping (generalisations about the personal attributes or characteristics of a group of people) and prejudice (usually negative attitudes and opinions about someone due to their perceived characteristics)
- Interestingly, within teams at similar levels of the hierarchy, we found that discrimination, bullying and harassment occurred. In some teams, staff who were different from their colleagues in terms of race, ethnicity, migration, language or religion did not feel included because of bullying and micro-aggressions
- The hierarchy and pressurised environment also affected people’s ability and willingness to report and challenge experiences of discrimination, with fears of being labelled a troublemaker, negative effects on career progression, or of upsetting team dynamics (‘rocking the boat’)
- To cope with bullying, prejudice, discrimination and harassment some racially and ethnically minoritised staff reported strategies such as maintaining closer working relationships with those from similar backgrounds, moving teams to somewhere more supportive or leaving the organisation altogether
This diagram was created to illustrate the findings more clearly;
What can I do with this?
I am a…
You can use this study to:
- reference in your essays or assignments (please see citation below)
- help support you feed back about your and others’ experiences on your course
- use your feedback opportunities to ask for raised awareness about organisational team dynamics and advice on how to manage during training and ahead of clinical placements. For example, to be prepared for potentially difficult conversations with colleagues, assessors or managers and what you can do if you experience or witness racial discrimination
- share this summary and use it as a basis for discussions with your colleagues and networks at work as part of supervision discussions, and at team meetings
- use the findings to support you to feed back about your experiences at work or to report unfair treatment
Use this study to:
- understand the importance of and the nuances involved in fostering inclusion within teams to promote staff well-being. Particularly, by understanding, recognising and addressing the subtle and more obvious dynamics at play within your team and across your workplace.
- reach out to staff members who may need extra support mentally or emotionally, and proactively support them at work (e.g., access to training and development opportunities, well-being support, support with reporting processes).
- prompt you to attend equality, diversity and inclusion training and to support staff members to do the same
- give you an opening to encourage open conversations between staff about team dynamics, and to remember to notice and openly value difference in your team
Use this study to gain buy-in from all leadership levels to:
- openly prioritise workforce diversity and to argue for sustained strategies targeting organisational, workplace, and individuals with transparent links to senior level accountability
- ask for and allocate sufficient resources for these sustained initiatives and their evaluation
- support racial and ethnic minority staff to be involved in the development of inclusion initiatives
- resource equality, diversity and inclusion training which incorporates experiential, perspective-taking and reflection, and promotes anti-racism, promotes allyship, bystander intervention and positive action
Use these findings to:
- argue for the implementation of sanctions by governing and regulatory bodies for failures to comply and progress on racial inequalities
- allocate funding to support the adequate resourcing of equality, diversity and inclusion initiatives (planning, implementation and long-term monitoring) in the health service
- mandate equality, diversity and inclusion training and awareness as part of the training curriculum for all healthcare professionals, to include both staff to staff as well as staff-patient interactions
You can use this study to:
- justify conducting research on racism in organisational culture and how it affects staff wellbeing, development, progression, and patient care
- explore the experiences of staff in other geographic settings
- appraise interventions aimed at reducing racialised inequalities in the health service
Have your say!
Tell us what you think of this study, make comments, suggestions or feedback to use here
I want to know more!
Read the primary paper here
Woodhead, C., Stoll, N., Harwood, H., Alexis, O., & Hatch, S.L.; TIDES Study Team “They created a team of almost entirely the people who work and are like them”: A qualitative study of organisational culture and racialised inequalities among healthcare staff. Sociology of Health & Illness. 2021;00-000-000. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9566.13414
Check out other TIDES publications here